Pinotage

The story

Pinotage is a wholly South African invention: on 17 November 1924 Prof. Abraham Izak Perold of Stellenbosch University crossed Pinot Noir with Cinsaut — then locally called "Hermitage," the direct source of the "-age" in the name — at the Welgevallen experimental farm. He planted the resulting seeds in 1925, a date the grape's own governing body still calls its "official birthday." Perold left for KWV in 1928 without developing the seedlings further, and Welgevallen grew overgrown; a young lecturer, Dr Charlie Niehaus, spotted the four abandoned seedlings during a farm clean-up and had them rescued and replanted. The vines moved to Elsenburg under C.J. Theron, were grafted onto Richter rootstocks in 1935, and C.T. de Waal made the first wine in 1941, the year Perold died. Shortened from "Perold's Hermitage x Pinot" to "Pinotage" for marketing in 1959, the same year a Bellevue-estate wine won the Cape Wine Show, Stellenbosch Farmers' Winery released that identical 1959 wine under the Lanzerac label in 1961 — one wine, two dates. Kanonkop planted its oldest surviving vines in 1953 under Paul Sauer, who had studied viticulture personally under Perold. After a damaging 1976 episode in which visiting British critics dismissed the wine and South African growers concluded it "had no future," uprooting established vineyards, Kanonkop winemaker Beyers Truter rebuilt the variety's reputation through the 1980s-90s, winning the Robert Mondavi Trophy for International Winemaker of the Year in 1991 for his 1989 Kanonkop Pinotage — then founded the Pinotage Association (1995) and the Absa Top 10 Pinotage Competition (1997), the institutions that now judge the grape he rehabilitated.

Insider story

The most-repeated version of Pinotage's 1976 crisis has the story backwards. The Pinotage Association's own 2007 text records that visiting British "Wine Masters" called the wine "hot and horrible" and compared it to "rusty nails" and acetone — but it was South African producers, not the critics, who then "decided Pinotage had no future" and uprooted established vines. The Association's current website has since moved that phrase into the critics' own mouths. Pinotage also almost had a different name entirely: Afrikaans cultivar history records that Perold and Prof. C.J. Theron weighed "Herminot" against "Pinotage" for the most promising of four surviving seedlings — three of the original four were discarded for cropping too lightly. VIVC's own passport record shows Perold's breeder notes and later DNA-marker analysis disagree on which parent was the mother: the breeder wrote "Pinot x Cinsaut," the confirmed markers read "Cinsaut x Pinot," making Cinsaut the seed parent — matching Afrikaans sources that call Cinsaut/Hermitage the pitouer (seed parent). Two of Pinotage's best stories surface only in Afrikaans: Clos Malverne's founders, friends since 1974, reunited over a 1985 Christmas braai and split their first blend 50/50 purely so as not to favour one grower's fruit over another's in a friendly tasting; the resulting 1997 Hidden Valley Pinotage is reportedly the only Pinotage ever awarded five stars by Winemag's editor. And in 2005, when Diemersfontein's Bertus "Starbucks" Fourie — inventor of the coffee-and-chocolate "Coffee Pinotage" style — left for KWV to build a rival "Café Culture" range, Diemersfontein's owners took legal action over ownership of his technique: a winery suing over who owned a flavour.

Technical deep dive

Pinotage is early-ripening with naturally high sugar accumulation and naturally high tannin, thriving in hot, dry sites — traits inherited from its vigorous Cinsaut parent. Mature-vine yields run around 50 hl/ha, up to 120 hl/ha at the extreme; bush-vine (gobelet) training is widely felt by producers to concentrate fruit more than trellising. The defining winemaking challenge is isoamyl acetate, a banana-ester compound that in excess produces the notorious burnt-rubber/paint/acetone fault; since the 1990s producers manage it with long, cool fermentations, moderated French/American oak, earlier picking for lower sugar, and whole-bunch fermentation to raise acidity and push toward a more Pinot-Noir-like profile. Kanonkop's Beyers Truter developed a specific extraction technique still in use: manual punch-downs every two hours (versus the industry-standard six-to-eight), fifteen minutes per tank, to maximise colour, tannin and complexity. The 'Coffee Pinotage' style pioneered at Diemersfontein gets its mocha character not from oak lactones but from the toasting of French oak insert staves suspended in tank after cold-soaking and hand-sorting out green material. WSET-SAT profile: deep/dark appearance; primary dark fruit (cherry, blackcurrant, blackberry, baked plum); secondary smoky/earthy notes, or chocolate/coffee in the stave-toasted style; tertiary dried fruit and tannic accents after ten-plus years; naturally high tannin, softened by long cool fermentation and limited maceration. Italian trade vocabulary adds banana, liquorice, dried leaves, rooibos, sweet pipe tobacco and even smoked bacon — banana being the pleasant face of the same isoamyl acetate that, at higher concentration, is the fault.

Industry secrets

The "Cape Blend" — Pinotage's flagship blend category — has no legal definition at all: German trade lexicon wein.plus states plainly there are "no legal requirements," and South Africa's only statutory number is a 20% minimum to name any variety on a label. The 30-70% Pinotage band everyone quotes is an industry convention (reportedly set by a 2002 Veritas committee, an attribution that is not independently confirmed) — and the Pinotage Association's own flagship "Perold Absa Cape Blend" competition page deliberately avoids stating a fixed percentage, describing the category only as containing "a significant component" of Pinotage. That is a governing body visibly declining to commit to a number it could easily cite if one existed. The market has a real secondary tier, but it is domestic, thin and concentrated on one cuvée: Strauss & Co (South Africa's main fine-wine auction house) has repeatedly sold Kanonkop Black Label verticals, with a 2008 six-bottle lot realising ZAR 15,243 (est. ZAR 13,500-15,000) in July 2020 — roughly ZAR 2,540/bottle. No ordinary retail price bands for Pinotage could be established in any currency; that gap is left open rather than estimated. Also worth knowing: Cabernet Sauvignon and Pinotage may each be named on a label only if vinified separately — co-fermented fruit cannot carry a dual-varietal claim.

For collectors

More red grapes

• Plant Robert
• Plavac Mali
• Plavina
• Plechistik
• Portugieser